Macau top court upholds ruling in Taipa Terminal concessionaire fine dispute

 set26

The Court of Final Appeal has upheld a ruling in favor of a concessionaire managing commercial spaces at the Taipa Ferry Terminal, rejecting an appeal by the Secretary for Transport and Public Works over a disputed fine.

The case stems from a June 2022 concession contract signed between the Macao SAR and an undisclosed company, granting exclusive rights to operate commercial areas at the terminal. Under the agreement, the firm was required to maintain two travel agency or hotel counters and four ATM machines.

Due to the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic, the Marine and Water Bureau (DSAMA) temporarily exempted the company from these obligations until March 2023. A further grace period was granted until June 30, 2023.

However, inspections later found only one travel agency counter in operation, prompting authorities to impose a fine of MOP60,000 (US$7,430) in December 2023.

The company challenged the sanction at the Court of Second Instance, which annulled the administrative decision. The Secretary for Transport and Public Works then appealed to the Court of Final Appeal.

The collective panel of judges ruled that the contractual fine should be interpreted as a maximum limit rather than a fixed amount. “The purpose of the penalty is both to compel compliance and to sanction breach,” the court said, stressing that proportional punishment is a fundamental principle of the sanctioning system.

By confirming that the fine was variable, the judges concluded that the administrative penalty had been misapplied. The appeal was dismissed, and the lower court’s decision in favor of the company was upheld.

https://macaubusiness.com/macau-top-court-upholds-ruling-in-taipa-terminal-concesisonaire-fine-dispute/


Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Macau’s airport expects 8.14mln passenger trips in 2026 helped by new routes, better frequency: operator

Fronteira do Aeroporto custa 381 milhões

Competitive analysis of medium-sized airports based on a tourism city